Prime Money Funds Offer Higher Returns, Less Risk Than Treasury, Bank. A recent study by
John Bilson, professor of finance at the Illinois Institute of Technology, supports the
push to "allow broker/dealers to use AAA rated money funds" as "qualified securities" under Rule 15c3-3, an initiative spearheaded by
Federated Investors and
Treasury Strategies. The paper, "
Eligible Securities for Customer Segregated Accounts" finds
treasury funds generally riskier than prime money funds (
the analysis uses statistical returns provided by
Crane Data LLC). Bilson also argues for a
zero percent "haircut" under Rule 15c3-
3.
Treasury money funds: offer lower rates of return not due to lower risk but "
because of the regulatory demand"; offer
more risk due to less "
room for diversification" and longer average maturities; and, "
may face higher operational risks" than prime funds, Bilson says. Copies of the study were provided to government officials and opinion makers.